Germany, once the economic engine of Europe, is now facing a serious downturn.
The country’s economy has hit a rough patch, marked by sluggish growth, a shrinking workforce, controversial decisions and structural challenges that threaten its reputation and long-term stability.
As Europe’s largest economy, Germany’s difficulties are not just a national concern but have significant implications for the entire continent.
Is Germany the “sick man of Europe” or is hope on the horizon?
An “old” and slowing economy
The truth is out there; Germany’s economy has struggled for the past few years.
It was the only G7 country to shrink in 2023 and is expected to grow by just 0.2% in 2024, the slowest among its peers.
This sluggish performance points to deeper issues that have been building for years.
Source: Statistisches Bundesamt
The nation’s labour force is shrinking, with the working-age population (those aged 15-64) expected to decline by 1% annually over the next half-decade.
This demographic trend, coupled with low productivity growth—less than 1% in recent years—has set a low bar for economic expansion.
Germany’s labour force is not only shrinking but also working fewer hours than in any other OECD country, exacerbating the productivity issue.
Source: Financial Times
Moreover, Germany’s public investment levels are alarmingly low. From 2018 to 2022, public investment averaged just 2.3% of GDP, one of the lowest among high-income countries, further limiting the country’s growth potential.
This underinvestment is evident in the country’s ageing infrastructure, which failed to meet the expectations of European football fans who descended on Germany this summer, shattering long-held positive prejudices about the nation’s transport system.
Citizens have long been complaining about cancelled trips, delayed arrivals and departures and low maintenance on infrastructure, deeming the once-praised “Deutsche Bahn” as simply unreliable.
Misguided environmentalism
Germany’s decision to shut down its nuclear power plants, even amidst an energy crisis, reflects a degrowth-oriented environmentalism that has backfired.
This has left the country more dependent on carbon-intensive energy sources and reliant on expensive imports, undermining its green transition.
Additionally, these plants were not only zero-carbon energy sources but also crucial for reducing Germany’s dependence on Russian natural gas.
With their closure, Germany now faces an energy crisis, forcing it to invest heavily in carbon-emitting natural gas plants to fill the gap left by nuclear energy.
This move has increased Germany’s vulnerability to energy shocks, especially given the volatile geopolitical landscape following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Geopolitical and strategic missteps
Germany’s geopolitical strategy has also come under scrutiny. The country has been slow to increase its defence budget, despite growing security threats in Europe.
Although Germany pledged to become Europe’s “arsenal of democracy”, its defence spending has not kept pace with these promises.
In fact, according to Politico, the German government recently announced a freeze on new military aid to Ukraine, redirecting funds to other domestic priorities.
This decision has raised concerns about Germany’s commitment to European security, particularly in the face of potential Russian aggression if Ukraine falls.
Additionally, Germany’s economic ties with China have become a point of contention.
Despite warnings from the government about the risks of over-reliance on the Chinese market, German companies, especially in the automotive sector, have continued to pour investment into China.
This “In China, for China” strategy, where companies reinvest profits earned in China back into the country, has led to a drop in Germany’s exports to China, one of the few bright spots in its economy during the aftermath of the early 2010s crisis.
The political environment in Germany is also problematic, with a fragmented political system that makes it difficult to implement the necessary reforms.
Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s coalition government is divided on key issues such as taxation, public investment, and regulation, leading to stalled progress.
The government’s approval ratings are low, and the far-right populist Alternative for Germany party is gaining popularity, further raising the fear and uncertainty that surrounds the nation.
A crumbling economic model
Germany’s economic model, once hailed as a success, is now showing signs of strain. The country has historically relied on its manufacturing sector and exports to drive growth.
However, the global shift towards services, coupled with the end of the era of globalization and rising protectionism, has hit Germany’s export-dependent economy hard.
In addition to this, China’s newly adopted strategy of copying and replacing German technology has undermined Germany’s manufacturing sector.as global trade has slowed, and China has now become a competitor.
Compounding these issues is Germany’s resistance to adopting digital technologies, leaving it behind in the global digital economy.
Despite being Europe’s largest economy, Germany’s role in the digital sector remains insignificant, further threatening its competitiveness on the global stage.
It has few major software companies, a stagnant R&D sector, and a housing market hindered by excessive regulation. The country’s bureaucracy is also sclerotic, slowing down vital processes like construction and technological adoption.
Europe’s path forward
Germany’s current predicament is the result of a combination of external shocks and self-inflicted wounds.
The country’s reluctance to increase public investment, embrace digital transformation, and adapt to changing global dynamics has left it vulnerable to economic stagnation.
Furthermore, its energy policy, defence strategy, and over-reliance on China have raised concerns about its long-term stability and influence in Europe.
To avoid further decline, Germany must address these challenges head-on. Increasing public investment, particularly in infrastructure and education, is essential for boosting productivity and supporting long-term growth.
Embracing digital technologies and reducing bureaucratic red tape can help modernize the economy and enhance its global competitiveness.
Additionally, a more strategic approach to energy policy and defence spending would ensure national security and reduce dependence on volatile foreign markets.
The ongoing economic slowdown in Germany has raised concerns about the overall health of the European economy, which could weigh heavily on the euro.
The European Central Bank (ECB) has already signalled a shift towards a rate-cutting cycle, a move typically aimed at stimulating growth.
However, if Germany’s economic stagnation persists, this could have the opposite effect, driving European investors towards more robust markets like the United States.
Germany’s future as Europe’s economic leader is at stake. As the U.S. steps back from its traditional leadership in European security, Germany must rise to the occasion.
Without decisive action, Europe risks becoming vulnerable to external threats, particularly from Russia. Germany’s leadership, both economically and militarily, is essential to safeguarding the stability and future of Europe.
The time for Germany to stop “messing around” and take decisive action is now.
The post Germany’s economic slowdown: the sick man of Europe once again? appeared first on Invezz
